Jonathan Yardley, Pulitzer-prize winning book critic for the Washington Post. WP obit (archived).
I’ve written about him before.
For seven years beginning in 2003, Mr. Yardley wrote a column every month or so called “Second Reading,” which reconsidered some of the notable but forgotten or neglected books — about 100 in all — that he retrieved from his bookshelves.
Among them was Edwin O’Connor’s 1964 novel of a vaudevillian, “I Was Dancing” (“I’d be hard-pressed to say that any book discussed therein is more undeservedly neglected than this one,” Mr. Yardley wrote), and Thornton Wilder’s “The Bridge of San Luis Rey.” “It is no exaggeration to say that on second reading,” he noted of Mr. Wilder Pulitzer-winning 1927 novel, “I was completely blown away, not so much by Wilder’s sensitive treatment of his central theme as by the richness and power of his prose.”
“I came to this task as a journalist, not a literateur, and I have remained one to this day,” he told readers of The Post in 2014 as he was retiring. “I have high literary standards and delight in the expression of strong opinion, literary and otherwise, but I also read a book as if I were a reporter: looking for what it is ‘about’ in the deepest sense of the word, determining what matters about it and what doesn’t, trying to give the reader a feel for what it is like as well as passing judgment on it.”
…
Perhaps the most pointed response to one of Mr. Yardley’s reviews came in a Gucci gift box wrapped in gold ribbon, not long after he published a blistering critique of Washington writer Kitty Kelley’s 1981 biography of actress Elizabeth Taylor.
“Inside,” Mr. Yardley told Time magazine, “was a bag of fish heads and a postcard of Liz Taylor giving me the finger.” An enclosed card was signed, “From the friends of Kitty Kelley.”
I never had a chance to meet Mr. Yardley, but I wish I had. From what came across in his writing, it seems like he was a swell guy, and it would have been a pleasure to sit and talk books with him.
Also, I would give my eye teeth for a postcard of Elizabeth Taylor giving me the finger.
Tinto Brass, director. NYT (share link, may require). IMDB.





